53 cards where the cards aren’t reprints and the card is tagged “aesthetic-counter”

Beastmaster Ascension (Zendikar #159)
Bloodchief Ascension (Zendikar #82)
Khalni Heart Expedition (Zendikar #167)
Promise of Loyalty (Commander 2021 #21)
Luminarch Ascension (Zendikar #25)
As Foretold (Amonkhet #42)
Quest for Renewal (Worldwake #110)
The Book of Exalted Deeds (Adventures in the Forgotten Realms #4)
Kaya the Inexorable (Kaldheim #218)
From the Catacombs (Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate #671)
Aquitect's Will (Lorwyn #52)
Quest for the Goblin Lord (Worldwake #86)
Quest for Ula's Temple (Worldwake #35)
Archmage Ascension (Zendikar #42)
The War in Heaven (Warhammer 40,000 Commander #69)
Mathas, Fiend Seeker (Commander 2017 #42)
Quest for Pure Flame (Zendikar #144)
Xolatoyac, the Smiling Flood (The Lost Caverns of Ixalan Commander #8)
Bounty of the Luxa (Amonkhet #196)
Quest for the Nihil Stone (Worldwake #64)
Liege of the Tangle (Scars of Mirrodin #123)
Pyromancer Ascension (Zendikar #143)
Rimefeather Owl (Coldsnap #42)
Aven Mimeomancer (Alara Reborn #2)
Quicksilver Fountain (Mirrodin #233)
Ior Ruin Expedition (Zendikar #49)
Arbiter of the Ideal (Born of the Gods #31)
Xira, the Golden Sting (Dominaria United Commander #48)
The Flood of Mars (Doctor Who #45)
Aurification (Onslaught #6)
Sensei Golden-Tail (Champions of Kamigawa #44)
Isareth the Awakener (Core Set 2019 #104)
Obsidian Fireheart (Zendikar #140)
Ascent of the Worthy (Kaldheim #202)
Quest for the Holy Relic (Zendikar #33)
Makeshift Mannequin (Lorwyn #124)
Bounty Hunter (Tempest #110)
Quest for the Gravelord (Zendikar #108)
Soul Stair Expedition (Zendikar #112)
Xathrid Gorgon (Magic 2013 #118)
Quest for Ancient Secrets (Zendikar #59)
Sunspring Expedition (Zendikar #37)
Zektar Shrine Expedition (Zendikar #155)
Rimescale Dragon (Coldsnap #95)
Barrin's Codex (Urza's Saga #286)
Quest for the Gemblades (Zendikar #177)
Cyclopean Tomb (Limited Edition Alpha #240)
Bloodletter Quill (Ravnica: City of Guilds #254)
Life Matrix (Legends #284)
Dread Wight (Ice Age #122)
As Luck Would Have It (Unstable #102)
Bant (Planechase Planes #4)
Red-Hot Hottie (Unhinged #86)

This search is finished. Now the real work can begin.