9 cards where (the lore includes “old” and the lore includes “rutstein”)

Crow of Dark Tidings (Commander Legends #115)
Geist-Fueled Scarecrow (Eldritch Moon #196)
Harrowing Journey (Dark Ascension #67)
Hinterland Logger // Timber Shredder (Shadows over Innistrad #210)
Hinterland Logger // Timber Shredder (Shadows over Innistrad #210)
Neglected Heirloom // Ashmouth Blade (Shadows over Innistrad #260)
Neglected Heirloom // Ashmouth Blade (Shadows over Innistrad #260)
Niblis of the Urn (Dark Ascension #16)
Old Rutstein (Innistrad: Crimson Vow #244)
Spore Crawler (Innistrad: Crimson Vow #222)
Toxic Scorpion (Innistrad: Crimson Vow #224)

Though this query has ended, its relics still slumber in New Argive.