38 cards where the cards aren’t reprints and the card is tagged “deprecated-p-t-counter”

Wall of Roots (Mirage #253)
Shield Sphere (Alliances #129)
Dwarven Armorer (Fallen Empires #50)
Contagion (Alliances #45)
Soul Exchange (Fallen Empires #43)
Lightning Serpent (Coldsnap #88)
Wall of Resistance (Mirage #46)
Baron Sengir (Homelands #41)
Clockwork Steed (Homelands #103)
Takklemaggot (Legends #119)
Necropolis (The Dark #105)
Dwarven Armory (Ice Age #182)
Jabari's Influence (Mirage #24)
Ebon Praetor (Fallen Empires #37)
Armor Thrull (Fallen Empires #33a)
Coral Reef (Homelands #24)
Consuming Ferocity (Mirage #166)
Clockwork Beast (Limited Edition Alpha #236)
Scars of the Veteran (Alliances #16)
Living Armor (The Dark #104)
Clockwork Avian (Antiquities #45)
Frankenstein's Monster (The Dark #45)
Clockwork Swarm (Homelands #104)
Balduvian Hydra (Ice Age #173)
Spirit Shackle (Legends #117)
Kjeldoran Home Guard (Alliances #8)
Fungus Elemental (Weatherlight #128)
Essence Flare (Ice Age #69)
Tin-Wing Chimera (Visions #157)
Lead-Belly Chimera (Visions #148)
Brass-Talon Chimera (Visions #142)
Iron-Heart Chimera (Visions #146)
Greater Werewolf (Homelands #51)
Sacred Boon (Ice Age #50)
Krovikan Plague (Alliances #54)
Lesser Werewolf (Legends #110)
Experiment Five (Mystery Booster Playtest Cards 2019 #73)
Orcish Catapult (Astral Cards #6)

This search is finished. Now the real work can begin.