46 cards where the cards aren’t reprints and the card is tagged “tutor-to-top”

Vampiric Tutor (Visions #72)
Enlightened Tutor (Mirage #14)
Mystical Tutor (Mirage #80)
Worldly Tutor (Mirage #255)
Imperial Seal (Portal Three Kingdoms #78)
Sterling Grove (Invasion #278)
Varragoth, Bloodsky Sire (Kaldheim #115)
Scheming Symmetry (Core Set 2020 #113)
Moon-Blessed Cleric (Adventures in the Forgotten Realms #26)
Conduit of Ruin (Battle for Zendikar #4)
Goblin Recruiter (Visions #80)
Liliana Vess (Lorwyn #121)
Personal Tutor (Portal #64)
Elvish Harbinger (Lorwyn #207)
Long-Term Plans (Scourge #38)
Forerunner of the Empire (Rivals of Ixalan #102)
Sylvan Tutor (Portal #188)
Forerunner of the Legion (Rivals of Ixalan #9)
Doomsday (Weatherlight #66)
Congregation at Dawn (Ravnica: City of Guilds #198)
Forerunner of the Coalition (Rivals of Ixalan #72)
Merrow Harbinger (Lorwyn #73)
Forerunner of the Heralds (Rivals of Ixalan #129)
Faerie Harbinger (Lorwyn #61)
Flamekin Harbinger (Lorwyn #167)
Treefolk Harbinger (Lorwyn #239)
Cruel Tutor (Portal #87)
Mwonvuli Beast Tracker (Magic 2013 #177)
Dwarven Recruiter (Odyssey #186)
Dune Mover (Phyrexia: All Will Be One #226)
Momir Vig, Simic Visionary (Dissension #118)
Brutalizer Exarch (New Phyrexia #105)
Insidious Dreams (Torment #66)
Boggart Harbinger (Lorwyn #102)
Bringer of the Black Dawn (Fifth Dawn #43)
Insatiable Avarice (Outlaws of Thunder Junction #91)
Giant Harbinger (Lorwyn #169)
Campus Guide (Strixhaven: School of Mages #252)
Giant Ladybug (Jumpstart 2022 #39)
Loam Larva (Oath of the Gatewatch #135)
Ainok Guide (Fate Reforged #121)
Compass Gnome (The Lost Caverns of Ixalan #250)
Scouting Trek (Invasion #210)
Kithkin Harbinger (Lorwyn #26)
Silver Deputy (Outlaws of Thunder Junction #248)
1996 World Champion (Celebration Cards #1)

The orcs’ banner sends a clear message: “You've reached the end of this search.”