8 cards where the illustration contains “star-shape”

Afflict (Odyssey #115)
Demonic Tutor (Limited Edition Alpha #104)
Ertai's Familiar (Weatherlight #38)
Iron Star (Seventh Edition #301)
Nova Pentacle (Legends #289)
Pentagram of the Ages (Ice Age #332)
Prismatic Omen (Shadowmoor #126)
Unholy Strength (Limited Edition Alpha #131)

The arc of my blade has carved a path of light to the end of these results.