11 cards where the illustration contains “bloodshot-eye”

Broken Concentration (Shadows over Innistrad #50)
Curse of Surveillance (Innistrad: Midnight Hunt #46)
Eye to Eye (Unhinged #54)
Giant Growth (Secret Lair Drop #717)
Horror of Horrors (Legends #106)
Paralyze (Fifth Edition #185)
Pestermite (Lorwyn #78)
Rabid Wombat (Legends #198)
Sensation Gorger (Morningtide #102)
Terror (Limited Edition Alpha #130)
The Secret Lair (2020 Heroes of the Realm #3)

The message was clear to Sorin—time to search for something else.