34 cards where the cards aren’t reprints and the card has the keyword “Monstrosity”

Hydra Broodmaster (Journey into Nyx #128)
Death Kiss (Commander Legends: Battle for Baldur's Gate #675)
Shipbreaker Kraken (Theros #63)
Fleecemane Lion (Theros #193)
Colossus of Akros (Theros #214)
Polukranos, World Eater (Theros #172)
Clay Golem (Forgotten Realms Commander #58)
Alpha Deathclaw (Fallout #91)
Stormbreath Dragon (Theros #143)
Splitting Slime (Conspiracy: Take the Crown #72)
Hundred-Handed One (Theros #20)
Sinuous Vermin (Conspiracy: Take the Crown #46)
Domesticated Hydra (Conspiracy: Take the Crown #63)
Kalemne's Captain (Commander 2015 #5)
Vitality Hunter (Commander 2020 #30)
Nemesis of Mortals (Theros #163)
Hythonia the Cruel (Theros #91)
Skittering Crustacean (Conspiracy: Take the Crown #36)
Grim Giganotosaurus (Jurassic World Collection #11)
Arbor Colossus (Theros #150)
Chillerpillar (Modern Horizons #43)
Sealock Monster (Theros #62)
Polis Crusher (Theros #198)
Stoneshock Giant (Theros #142)
Ember Swallower (Theros #120)
Nessian Asp (Theros #164)
Keepsake Gorgon (Theros #93)
Fleetfeather Cockatrice (Journey into Nyx #149)
Wildfire Cerberus (Journey into Nyx #116)
Ill-Tempered Cyclops (Theros #125)
Swarmborn Giant (Journey into Nyx #144)
Ravenous Leucrocota (Journey into Nyx #136)
Gluttonous Cyclops (Journey into Nyx #99)
Jetpack Death Seltzer (Unfinity Sticker Sheets #20)

This search is finished. Now the real work can begin.