40 cards where the illustration contains “eye-shadow”

Acolyte of Xathrid (Magic 2010 #83)
Agent of Masks (Modern Masters 2017 #149)
Angel (Magic Player Rewards 2004 #2)
Balance (From the Vault: Exiled #1)
Celebrity Fencer (Streets of New Capenna #7)
Channeler Initiate (Amonkhet #160)
Counterspell (Ice Age #64)
Daring Apprentice (Eighth Edition #73)
Elven Cache (Portal #164)
Eternal Witness (Secret Lair Drop #43)
Exotic Curse (Invasion #105)
Frightful Delusion (Innistrad #57)
Gala Greeters (Streets of New Capenna #453)
Greenweaver Druid (Zendikar #164)
Haze of Pollen (Amonkhet #171)
Icing Manipulator (Unfinity #142)
Isareth the Awakener (Core Set 2019 #104)
Joven (Homelands #77)
Marchesa, the Black Rose (Conspiracy #49)
Martyr's Cause (Urza's Legacy #13)
Mission Briefing (Guilds of Ravnica #44)
Never Happened (Guilds of Ravnica #80)
Nourish (Darksteel #78)
Olivia, Mobilized for War (Secret Lair Drop #699)
Restoration Angel (Avacyn Restored #32)
Rhystic Scrying (Prophecy #44)
Rumor Gatherer (Streets of New Capenna #29)
Ruthless Sniper (Amonkhet #105)
Serene Sleuth (Murders at Karlov Manor Commander #14)
Shaman of Spring (Magic 2015 #199)
Shapeshifter (Fifth Edition #398)
Sovereign's Realm (Conspiracy: Take the Crown #10)
Starlight Invoker (Legions #20)
Stern Mentor (Avacyn Restored #77)
Syncopate (Return to Ravnica #54)
Tajuru Stalwart (Battle for Zendikar #194)
Tavern Swindler (Return to Ravnica #79)
Ultimate Price (Friday Night Magic 2015 #10)
Vampire (Innistrad: Crimson Vow Tokens #16)
Vannifar, Evolved Enigma (Murders at Karlov Manor #373)

Though this query has ended, its relics still slumber in New Argive.